Henry Parker
New York City’s original Pennsylvania Station was one of the most breathtaking architectural marvels of the early 20th century. Opened in 1910, this massive transportation hub was designed to be the grand entrance to the city, a fitting welcome for travelers arriving by train. But by the 1960s, this magnificent building was gone. The story of Pennsylvania Station—its stunning beauty, its bustling daily life, and its eventual demolition—is a tale of ambition, loss, and controversy.
The construction of Pennsylvania Station began in the early 1900s. At the time, the old station, located at the corner of 33rd Street and 7th Avenue, was becoming too small for the growing number of train passengers traveling to and from New York. The Pennsylvania Railroad, which operated the station, wanted to create something that would reflect the city’s power and status. They turned to two of the most respected architects of the day: Charles McKim and William Rutherford Mead, both of the architectural firm McKim, Mead & White.
The design of the station was inspired by the grandeur of classical Roman architecture. The building featured a huge classical facade, complete with massive columns and arches. Inside, the space was even more impressive. The main waiting room, often described as the heart of the station, was the centerpiece of the building. It was one of the largest indoor spaces in the world at the time. The high vaulted ceiling, decorated with a beautiful sky-blue paint job, made the room feel open and airy. The room was 150 feet long, 120 feet wide, and 120 feet tall. It could hold up to 1,200 people at once, making it a central gathering place for travelers.
Read more
The station’s interior was equally luxurious. The marble floors, walls, and columns gave the space a polished and elegant look. Bronze chandeliers hung from the ceiling, casting a warm glow on the bustling crowds. The large arched windows, made of glass, filled the space with natural light, making it feel even more open and inviting. Even the ticket counters were designed with grandeur in mind. They were made of polished marble and decorated with intricate designs, showing that even the smallest details were treated with care.
For the people of New York, the station became a symbol of the city’s progress and ambition. At its peak, the station was one of the busiest in the world. Each day, thousands of people passed through its halls. It served as a major point of entry to the city for travelers coming in by train. The station was more than just a transportation hub; it was a gathering place, a place to meet friends, and a place to pause before continuing on to other parts of the city. The famous “kissing gallery” was located at one end of the waiting room, where passengers would wait for loved ones to arrive. It became a romantic symbol of New York and the arrival of so many new beginnings.
However, despite its beauty, Pennsylvania Station’s days were numbered. The rapid growth of New York in the early 20th century meant that the city needed more space for its growing transportation network. The rise of cars and buses further reduced the station’s importance as a central hub for travelers. The Pennsylvania Railroad, which owned the station, was struggling financially and saw an opportunity to make money by redeveloping the land on which the station stood.
In the 1950s, the Pennsylvania Railroad made plans to demolish the iconic station and replace it with a new, more modern facility. The company decided to build the new station underground, under a vast office building called the Madison Square Garden, which would sit on top of it. The plan for a new, functional, but less beautiful station was part of the post-World War II trend of urban renewal. The idea was to modernize the city’s infrastructure, but the cost was a loss of a key piece of New York’s architectural history.
The demolition of Pennsylvania Station began in 1963, and it happened quickly. Over the span of just a few months, the building was torn down. The grand waiting room, once filled with passengers and light, was replaced by the dull, cramped spaces of the new underground station. The destruction of the building sparked outrage among New Yorkers and architects alike. People were upset that such a grand, historic structure was being replaced by a generic, utilitarian space. The loss of the station became a symbol of the city’s rapid modernization and a lack of respect for its architectural past.
The demolition of Pennsylvania Station was not only a loss for the city’s architecture but also for its cultural heritage. The building had represented the hopes and dreams of a generation. It had served as a gateway to the city for millions of people and had been a symbol of New York’s ambition and strength. When it was destroyed, many felt as though a part of the city’s soul had been lost.
In the years that followed the demolition, the loss of Pennsylvania Station led to changes in the way cities thought about their historic buildings. In the wake of the destruction, preservation efforts grew stronger. People began to realize how important it was to protect architectural landmarks from being torn down in the name of progress. The fight to save Pennsylvania Station ultimately led to the creation of New York City’s Landmarks Preservation Commission in 1965, which was designed to protect the city’s historic buildings from similar fates.
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings